logo.gif (5796 bytes)

Full vs. Limited Context Hierarchical Menu Structures for Web Site Navigation with Frames

 

3. RESULTS

3.1 Completion Time
Figure 1 shows that the subjects performed their tasks faster on average with the full context menu than with the limited context menu. The t-test was computed on the results and it was determined that there was no significant difference between the completion times of both types of frames. (T-stat = -0.71 < 0.05)

Table 1. Completion Time: (S.D. in parenthesis)

Model

Full Context

Limited Context

Reaction Time

288.0 (76.4)

302.8 (55.6)



Figure 1. Completion Time





3.2 Accuracy of Information Retrieval
Figure 2 shows that the full Context menu had a higher number of errors than the limited context menu. The t-test was computed on the results and the Number of errors was determined to be significantly different for both types of frames. (T-stat = 0.68 > 0.05)

Table 2. Accuracy of Information Retrieval: (S.D. in parenthesis)

Model

Full Context

Limited Context

Error Frequency

2.5 (3.37)

1.8 (1.14)



Figure 2. Accuracy of Information Retrieval





3.3 Subjective Ranking
Figure 3 shows that, on average, the subjects preferred the full context menu structure to the limited context menu structure. The t-test was computed on the results and it was determined that the subjective ratings for the full context menu was significantly different from the subjective ratings for the limited context menu. (T-stat = 1.78 > 0.05)

Table 3. Subjective Ranking: (S.D. in parenthesis)

Model

Full Context

Limited Context

Subjective Ratings

8.3 (2.45)

7.4 (1.90)



Figure 3. Subjective Ranking



  Department of Computer Sciences
Direct questions and comments to the student editorial team