Return to Bibliography

Schudson, Michael.  "Paper Tigers: A Sociologist Follows Cultural Studies into the Wilderness." Lingua Franca (August, 1997).

In this piece, which is in part a review of Donna Haraway's essay, "Teddy bear Patriarchy," and part diatribe against Cultural Studies, Schudson begins by arguing that cultural studies is "not sociological enough," noting in particular that it is too reflexive and self-conscious about its politics and not enough so when is comes to reviewing scholarship.  After offering a brief summary of Haraway's reading of the Museum of Natural History's African Hall, and an even briefer description of what he takes to be the vocation of cultural studies, Schudson admits that his quarrel is not so much with Haraway's article but with its "celebrity" in the field.  Despite this admission, he then goes on to critique Haraway's article "on its own terms," bringing up several valid and insightful criticisms, without ever offering sufficient evidence of the article's canonical place in cultural studies.  Ultimately, Haraway falls short for Schudson in her lack of historical knowledge of the which may very well be a valid claim (one should have a sufficient knowledge of Haraway's piece before engaging Schudson), but Schudson himself fails to show that the article is indicative of some larger shortcoming of cultural studies.  In the end, Schudson's assertions that cultural studies scholarship should be more self critical may ring true with many in the field, but Schudson's own lack of rigor in engaging the discipline with such little depth offers little in the way of a useful starting point for this project. [E. Martini.]