Evaluation
Monopoly was a very popular game in the 1930s and 40s, but it was not the
only popular game of the time period. Ann Neville, a
Greenbelt resident during the
period recalls playing Cribbage and
Parcheesi. Her
family stored the Parcheesi box in the bookcase, but the Parcheesi board,
itself, was kept next to her grandpa's chair. A Monopoly box is
relatively
the same size as a Parcheesi box and it is therefore possible that it
could have been kept in a bookcase as well. The game itself, though, was
much different than Parcheesi. Parcheesi originated in India "a millenium
or two ago" while Monopoly emerged in America in the 1900s.(Jackson 108)
Parcheesi is a simple move and attack game, while Monopoly is a complex
game involving the buying, selling, and trading of real estate. Another
popular game of the 1930s with complex rules was Mah
jong.(Wai Ling)
Mrs. Markfield, a resident of early Greenbelt,
"would get together on a regular basis with her friends and her sister to
play Mah jong"(Wai Ling). She usually played with the same group of
friends, though, because the rules were so complicated to learn and one
"needed to learn all of the rules of the game before he or she was able to
play"(Wai Ling). What Parcheesi, Monopoly, and Mah jong all have in
common is that they have all withstood the test of time and are all still
popular entertainment today.
Mah jong
An amazing comparison can be found when comparing Monopoly in the 1930s to
Monopoly today. The boxes, boards, and playing pieces have changed
slightly, but the most striking difference is the homemade rules that have
been created over the years. For instance, the homemade Free Parking rule
involving "the tucking away of money paid for fines and taxes in Free
Parking, to be picked up by whoever lands in the space"(Costello 63). The
Free Parking space was meant to be a place of rest and this homemade rule
only prolongs the game. Another created rule is the practice of granting
immunity. "Immunity is the time-honored ploy wherein player A and player
B make a deal in which, along with whatever cash and property changes
hands, player A also gets a free ride on player B's properties"(Costello
64). According to Costello, this practice is "counter to the spirit as
well as the letter of the rules"(Costello 63).
A modern Monopoly box
Identification
Cultural Analysis
Interpretation
Works Cited
To return to Erin Kelman's home page click here